Researchers outline a new pavement maintenance model that accounts for future uncertainties in cost and deterioration

Researchers outline a new pavement maintenance model that accounts for future uncertainties in cost and deterioration
The researchers found that traditional long-term strategies, which employ rigid schedules for future road treatments, may overestimate total life-cycle costs. Credit: Nextvoyage/Pexels

In 2017, the American Society of Civil Engineer's Infrastructure Report Card gave America's infrastructure an overall grade of a D+. Given that the report found the U.S. had been paying for just half of its infrastructure needs, the low grade unfortunately wasn't surprising.

To solve the crisis, researchers Fengdi Guo, Jeremy Gregory, and Randolph Kirchain at the MIT Concrete Sustainability Hub have proposed a new approach to long-term infrastructure preservation. The approach, outlined in the Journal of the Transportation Research Board, is called simulation life-cycle cost analysis (LCCA).

Like other long-term pavement preservation strategies, this new MIT method takes a life-cycle cost analysis perspective, involving factoring in the of future maintenance to the total cost of a project in addition to the initial costs of construction.

But what sets MIT's simulation optimization LCCA apart from the other approaches is its embrace of various uncertainties, particularly related to the timing and methods used to repair and rehabilitate pavements—known as the treatment schedule.

Currently, traditional long-term strategies employ a rigid schedule for future road treatments, explains Guo. "One drawback of a rigid schedule," he says, "is that it may overestimate the total life-cycle cost."

Such strategies also assume that predetermined investments or decisions will result in a predictable outcome—for example, that a planned investment in a highway will produce a corresponding future improvement in its performance and quality.

The MIT approach, however, acknowledges that this is often not the case.

Conditions like construction costs, maintenance costs, and deterioration processes can change unpredictably over the course of a project's lifetime. This means that a set investment may not produce a set result, and—if pavements deteriorate faster than expected—may lead to unbudgeted repairs or even unsafe conditions.

To manage these uncertainties, MIT researchers assemble pricing, deterioration, and potential treatment schedule information to inform their predictions. They then predict the many possible future prices of asphalt and concrete—two key paving materials.

The next part of the process is what gives simulation optimization its name—an algorithm simulates numerous potential scenarios in pricing and deterioration from year to year.

"We have simulated around 1,000 scenarios and, for each scenario, the future cost and deterioration rate are fixed," Guo says.

After completing the simulations, optimization then comes into play. "For each simulated scenario we can find an optimal treatment schedule," says Guo, "and based on this schedule we can then calculate its life cycle costs."

All of these simulated and then optimized results are then compiled to show the life cycle cost distribution of different pavement design alternatives. Based on these distributions, the best design is selected.

Essentially, this new method considers the uncertainty of both treatment timing and treatment actions to reduce a project's life cycle cost. This results in different, more beneficial pavement designs.

And when compared to the costs of conventional methods, the advantages of simulation optimization become apparent.

In one case study of a mile-long length of road over a 35-year period, the simulation optimization model cost $150,000 less per mile than conventional methods when considering lifecycle cost.

The same is true of a road similar in length but with even more traffic flow. When the road saw nearly six times the truck traffic, the simulation optimization model cost $100,000 less per mile over its lifecycle.

At a time when funding for infrastructure is scarce, these case studies demonstrate that a optimization model will allow agencies to make better informed paving decisions that will prove more cost effective over a pavement's life cycle.

More information: Fengdi Guo et al. Probabilistic Life-Cycle Cost Analysis of Pavements Based on Simulation Optimization, Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board (2019). DOI: 10.1177/0361198119838984

This story is republished courtesy of MIT News (web.mit.edu/newsoffice/), a popular site that covers news about MIT research, innovation and teaching.

Citation: Researchers outline a new pavement maintenance model that accounts for future uncertainties in cost and deterioration (2019, April 9) retrieved 28 March 2024 from https://phys.org/news/2019-04-outline-pavement-maintenance-accounts-future.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

With buildings and infrastructure, it pays to take a life-cycle perspective

12 shares

Feedback to editors